FOS decisions / Data Breach
Data Breach
Financial Ombudsman Service final decisions, reproduced verbatim from the FOS published decisions register.
Decisions
10
Upheld
5
Not upheld
5
Avg redress
£345
Upheld complaints (5)
Equifax Limited
DRN-5851014A credit reference agency must provide reasonable support and engagement when a consumer seeks to understand and improve their B2B credit score, even if the ultimate lending decision remains with the lender.
UpheldAug 2025National Westminster Bank Public Limited Company
DRN-6137280A financial institution can only be held liable for the impact of unauthorised data access that it could reasonably have discovered and prevented, not for the downstream criminal harassment actions of third parties.
UpheldRedress £1,000Phoenix Life Limited
DRN-6200079Financial businesses must handle customer personal information securely under GDPR and DPA 2018, and fair compensation should reflect distress and inconvenience caused by breaches.
UpheldRoyal London Mutual Insurance Society, Limited
DRN-6261932A financial services provider must not disclose personal data or policy information to third parties without the customer's explicit written authority.
UpheldTRANSUNION INTERNATIONAL UK LIMITED
DRN-6236733A credit reference agency must properly respond to subject access requests within statutory timeframes and must not disclose personal health information without consent.
UpheldRedress £500
Not-upheld complaints (5)
National Westminster Bank Plc
DRN-6132527Compensation for distress and inconvenience caused by data protection request handling errors should be assessed based on the size of errors, duration, bank's response, and inconvenience suffered to the individual.
Not upheldBank of Scotland plc trading as Halifax
DRN-6193392An executor derives authority from the will itself upon the deceased's death, not from a grant of probate, and may therefore request account information from a bank without requiring probate.
Not upheldAJ Bell Securities Limited
DRN-5972730A business must retain personal data only as long as reasonably necessary for its stated purposes, but retention for regulatory compliance purposes may justify longer retention periods even after customer relationship ends.
Not upheldThe Royal London Mutual Insurance Society
DRN-6190677A firm must conduct its business with due skill, care and diligence, and it is reasonable to use standard Royal Mail post to return document copies absent a specific request for registered post.
Not upheldExperian Limited
DRN-6053066A Credit Reference Agency is not responsible for the accuracy of data it receives from data providers unless it fails to take reasonable steps to investigate disputes.
Not upheld