FOS decisions / Pension Transfer
Pension Transfer
Financial Ombudsman Service final decisions, reproduced verbatim from the FOS published decisions register.
Decisions
61
Upheld
43
Not upheld
18
Avg redress
£576
Upheld complaints (43)
Woodgrange Associates (IFA) Ltd
DRN-6099676A financial adviser must provide suitable advice for pension transfers that reflects the consumer's stated needs, circumstances, and vulnerability, and must provide adequate suitability reports for the recommended course of action.
UpheldJan 2026Independent Financial Services 4 You Ltd
DRN-6057249A regulated financial adviser providing pension transfer advice must ensure the consumer receives a suitable recommendation directly, and cannot rely on an unregulated third party to communicate its advice.
UpheldSept 2025HARBOUR ROCK CAPITAL LIMITED
DRN-5792579A pension transfer from a Defined Benefits Pension to a Personal Pension was unsuitable where the critical yield required (11%) significantly exceeded regulatory discount rates and the consumer lacked capacity for loss, despite urgent need
UpheldAug 2025JLT Wealth Management Limited
DRN-5732954A firm must act honestly, fairly and professionally in accordance with the best interests of its client when advising on defined benefit pension transfers, and must communicate clearly about suitability regardless of whether the client foll
UpheldJun 2025DTE Risk and Financial Management Limited
DRN-5698559Pension transfer advice must be suitable based on the consumer's circumstances, objectives, and risk profile, with full consideration of costs and alternatives.
UpheldJun 2025Scottish Widows Limited
DRN-6091126A pension provider must act promptly and without unreasonable delay when processing a pension transfer following a court order, and should compensate for demonstrable financial losses resulting from such delays.
UpheldJun 2025Alan Boswell Insurance Brokers Limited
DRN-5611998A pension transfer must be suitable based on the consumer's circumstances, attitude to risk, and understanding of the critical yield required, rather than relying on illustrations showing only optimistic growth scenarios.
UpheldMay 2025Frenkel Topping Limited
DRN-6103394A transfer from a defined benefit pension scheme should not be recommended unless it is clearly in the client's best interests, particularly where the scheme provides guaranteed income for life and the critical yield required is significant
UpheldMay 2025Tideway Investment Partners LLP
DRN-5014846Unsuitable pension transfer advice must be remedied by calculating losses including the value of lost discretionary dependant benefits, applying actuarial assumptions about likelihood and quantum of such benefits.
UpheldDec 2023West Park Investment Partnership Limited
DRN-6048275A financial adviser is responsible for ensuring pension transfer advice is suitable even when delegated to another authorised firm, and must manage investments according to the client's stated risk profile.
UpheldAscot Lloyd Limited
DRN-6014110A defined-benefit pension transfer is assumed unsuitable unless the adviser can clearly demonstrate it is in the client's best interests.
UpheldDTE Risk and Financial Management Limited
DRN-5834444A pension transfer to a SIPP must be suitable based on the consumer's actual circumstances and objectives, not generic objectives, and must not be recommended primarily to generate adviser fees.
UpheldRadcliffe & Company (Life & Pensions) Limited
DRN-5838128A pension transfer is unsuitable if it results in financial loss to the consumer, assessed by comparing the defined benefit value foregone against the actual personal pension value achieved.
UpheldHARBOUR ROCK CAPITAL LIMITED
DRN-5222710A firm must not proceed with an unsuitable DB pension transfer recommendation simply because a client insists on it without ensuring the client fully understands the benefits being given up.
UpheldProfile Financial Solutions Limited
DRN-5306765A pension transfer recommendation must be based on a complete fact find and justified by clear analysis showing it is in the consumer's best interests, particularly where the new arrangement has higher costs.
UpheldQuilter Financial Services Limited
DRN-5764409A pension transfer recommendation must be suitable for the consumer's circumstances, taking into account their attitude to risk, investment experience, and the comparison of charges and benefits between the existing and proposed arrangement
UpheldSt. James's Place Wealth Management Plc
DRN-5568102Pension transfer advice must be suitable, with clear consideration and explanation of higher charges, and customers must receive all paid-for ongoing advice reviews.
UpheldPeter Stewart Associates Limited
DRN-5750175Pension transfer advice must be suitable for the consumer's actual risk profile and circumstances, and a firm cannot rely on a consumer's stated medium risk tolerance if the evidence suggests they are actually low-risk.
UpheldWoodgrange Associates
DRN-5696008A financial adviser's unsuitable advice to transfer defined benefit pensions to a personal pension is actionable even when made decades earlier, and liability remains with the original adviser or their successor firm regardless of corporate
UpheldPension Income Planning Limited
DRN-6117534A transfer from a defined benefit pension to a drawdown plan must be in the consumer's best interest, with compelling reasons required when the consumer would be financially worse off in retirement.
UpheldQuilter Financial Services Limited
DRN-5970198A firm must provide suitable advice on defined-benefit pension transfers and treat customers fairly by having regard to their interests and circumstances.
UpheldChapelwood Financial Planning Ltd
DRN-4158196Advice to transfer defined benefit pension benefits must be suitable for the individual's circumstances, taking into account the critical yield required and the member's ability to achieve it through investment returns.
UpheldHugh James Solicitors
DRN-4489987Pension transfer advice must be suitable, and where unsuitable, redress must be calculated using FCA-approved methodology to determine if the transferred value exceeds the cost of replicating the deferred benefits.
UpheldHugh James Solicitors
DRN-4528978A pension transfer from a defined benefit scheme is unsuitable if it fails to prioritise the security and value of accrued benefits, even if the consumer's stated objectives at the time might have supported the transfer.
UpheldCST Wealth Management Limited
DRN-4038537Advice to transfer from a defined benefit pension scheme must be suitable having regard to the consumer's circumstances, needs, and the critical yield required to match the guaranteed benefits being surrendered.
UpheldCST Wealth Management Limited
DRN-4587832A defined benefit pension transfer must be presumed unsuitable unless it can be clearly demonstrated to be in the individual's best interests, particularly where the member is young with dependents and stable defined benefits.
UpheldLighthouse Advisory Services Limited
DRN-4505944Firms must follow the FCA's BSPS Defined Benefit Advice Assessment Tool rules when reviewing pension transfer suitability under the redress scheme, properly documenting their reasoning for final judgments.
UpheldXPAT Limited
DRN-6003827A financial adviser must provide clear, transparent fee disclosure and implement services as agreed in the terms of engagement.
UpheldFinancial Professionals (NI) Ltd
DRN-5740723Defined-benefit pension transfers must not be recommended unless the advice is suitable for the consumer's circumstances, taking into account their financial difficulties, income shortfall, and the critical yield required to match the given
UpheldReAssure Limited
DRN-6249992A pension provider must process transfers correctly and in a timely manner; any gains accruing during delays caused by the provider's error should be assessed at the effective completion date when all requirements were met.
UpheldRedress £1,001Tideway Investment Partners LLP
DRN-5973315A pension transfer adviser must ensure that advice to transfer defined benefit pensions is suitable having regard to the consumer's circumstances, needs, and the guarantees being surrendered.
UpheldJLT Wealth Management Limited
DRN-5733001Advice to transfer defined benefit pension benefits must be suitable to the consumer's circumstances, taking into account attitude to risk, retirement objectives, and the critical yield analysis.
UpheldJLT Wealth Management Limited
DRN-5733042Advice to transfer out of a defined benefit pension scheme must be suitable having regard to the member's circumstances, attitude to risk, and the critical yield analysis.
UpheldLondon & Colonial Services Limited
DRN-5644544A pension administrator must undertake sufficient due diligence on intermediaries and investments to meet its regulatory obligations and protect consumers from fraud.
UpheldQuilter Financial Services Limited
DRN-5735129A transfer from a Defined Benefit pension scheme is presumed unsuitable unless the adviser clearly demonstrates on contemporary evidence that the transfer is in the consumer's best interests.
UpheldAscot Lloyd Limited
DRN-5677056A pension transfer must be suitable and demonstrably better for the consumer, with clear justification for moving away from existing protections and benefits.
UpheldQuilter Financial Services Limited
DRN-6014738A transfer from a defined benefit pension scheme must be recommended only where it is clearly in the consumer's best interests, considering their circumstances, the scheme's benefits, and available alternatives.
UpheldQuilter Financial Services Limited
DRN-6121325A pension switch must be recommended only where the benefits clearly outweigh increased costs, and transparency of charges alone is insufficient justification for a switch that increases total costs substantially.
UpheldCharles Derby Financial Services Limited
DRN-6107723Pension transfer advice must properly explore reasonable alternatives to avoid loss of valuable guaranteed benefits before recommending surrender of those benefits.
UpheldHarbour Rock Capital Limited
DRN-6205831A transfer of occupational pension scheme benefits away from guaranteed income must be recommended only if suitable for the client's circumstances, and an adviser cannot simply accept an 'insistent client' instruction to proceed against adv
UpheldFrancis Clark Financial Planning Limited
DRN-5798873A complaint about unsuitable pension transfer advice must be referred within three years of when the complainant became aware (or ought reasonably to have become aware) that they had cause for complaint, not necessarily from the date of the
UpheldEvelyn Partners Financial Planning Limited
DRN-6042571A personal pension transfer recommendation must be suitable for the consumer's circumstances, attitude to risk, and financial objectives at the time of advice.
UpheldZurich Assurance Ltd
DRN-5262223A pension transfer scheme must provide appropriate warnings and information to consumers, but is not responsible for verifying third-party regulators or the investment choices made after transfer when the consumer had opportunities to seek
Upheld
Not-upheld complaints (18)
Harbour Rock Capital Limited
DRN-6069532A firm advising on defined benefits pension transfer must demonstrate on contemporary evidence that transfer is in the client's best interests, with the starting position being that transfer is unsuitable.
Not upheldDec 2025Phoenix Life Limited
DRN-6181228A pension provider can require a Pension Advice Declaration form as a legal requirement for transfers of safeguarded benefits over £30,000, regardless of the consumer's preference to proceed without advice.
Not upheldAug 2025Whiting Group Limited
DRN-5840170A pension transfer recommendation must be clear, fair and not misleading, with proper prominence given to the guaranteed benefits of a defined benefit pension versus the uncertain returns of a personal pension arrangement.
Not upheldJun 2025St. James's Place Wealth Management Plc
DRN-6030737A pension transfer recommendation must be in the consumer's best interests, taking into account costs, guarantees lost, and suitability of the recommended investment approach.
Not upheldHarbour Rock Capital Limited
DRN-5974143A pension transfer to a SIPP is unsuitable if it is not in the consumer's best interests and alternatives have not been properly considered, particularly where the consumer has modest objectives that could be met through existing arrangemen
Not upheldHarbour Rock Capital Limited
DRN-5944709A pension transfer advice is suitable if it meets the customer's identified needs and the recommended provider offers appropriate investment options, even if not the cheapest option on the market.
Not upheldSt. James's Place Wealth Management Plc
DRN-6140175A tied financial adviser can only recommend products from their own provider, and suitability must be assessed by comparing the recommended product against the existing arrangement rather than against unavailable alternatives.
Not upheldPension Insurance Corporation plc
DRN-6157505A pension provider's transfer value quotation is not guaranteed and must be recalculated monthly based on current economic assumptions including interest rates and inflation, with the provider remaining obligated to pay the guaranteed pensi
Not upheldZurich Assurance Ltd
DRN-6184621A pension transfer provider is not responsible for delays caused by the consumer's failure to provide required documentation or complete regulatory safeguarding requirements.
Not upheldQuilter Financial Services Limited
DRN-6253290A pension transfer must be suitable based on the consumer's circumstances, and the adviser must properly assess whether the consumer can afford to lose the security of guaranteed defined benefit income.
Not upheldOrigen Financial Services Limited
DRN-6260640A firm must act in a client's best interests even when treating them as an insistent client, and must adequately challenge unsuitable courses of action and ensure full understanding of long-term implications.
Not upheldHansells Solicitors
DRN-6261489Loss calculations for unsuitable DB pension transfer advice must be conducted in accordance with FCA Handbook DISP App 4, and a consumer does not have a right to redress beyond the calculated loss amount even if they believe the original ad
Not upheldWPS ADVISORY Ltd
DRN-6263934A defined benefit pension scheme offering a transfer value enhancement above the statutory minimum does not necessarily mean a consumer should transfer, particularly when they have limited investment experience and are not approaching retir
Not upheldSt. James's Place Wealth Management Plc
DRN-6266062A pension transfer recommendation must be suitable based on documented objectives and attitude to risk, with proper disclosure of charges and outperformance requirements.
Not upheldScottish Equitable Plc
DRN-6215241Pension providers must apply red flags under the Occupational and Personal Pension Schemes (Conditions for Transfers) Regulations 2021 when a transfer involves financial incentives, which removes statutory transfer rights.
Not upheldZurich Assurance Ltd
DRN-6174912Pension transfer providers must conduct appropriate due diligence under the Occupational and Personal Pension Schemes (Conditions for Transfers) Regulations 2021, including MoneyHelper referrals, and are not required to expedite these proce
Not upheldHARBOUR ROCK CAPITAL LIMITED
DRN-5759984Advice to transfer from an occupational pension scheme must be suitable to the consumer's circumstances, objectives, and health status.
Not upheldSt. James's Place Wealth Management Plc
DRN-5796503A pension transfer must be suitable based on the specific circumstances and objectives of the consumer, with clear demonstration that benefits outweigh costs and risks.
Not upheld